I
was reflecting this week back to a short-term mission trip by a couple of the
folks from a church I once served. To
give you full disclosure when this project was proposed I expressed opposition
to the project. I recommended that the
trip not happen. The church board
decided that while the project would not be funded by church funds the church
would encourage the four people going and would appeal for members to privately
contribute to the trip.
So
it was that four people from our congregation went to the other side of the
world for a 10-day mission trip. By the
time you count almost 2 days travel each way and a day and a half to recover
from jet lag once there the trip was more of a 5-day mission trip. While there the team painted several
classrooms in a school and “helped” with a VBS program. I suppose that in the entire community, city,
or nation there were no Christians who were painters who could have used the
work, so it was essential for Americans to come and paint for these “backward
natives”. Now we all know how valuable
VBS can be. But this VBS was not long on
the schedule, but was put together at the last minute so the short term
“missionaries” could have something to do.
However, the “missionaries” didn’t speak the native language so they
were relegated to helping the kids do crafts.
Having not had time to plan extensively the locals were pressed into a
“busy work” VBS so there would be lessons.
The American “missionaries” did crafts, namely they colored pictures out
of coloring books. Yes, we sent people
half way around the world to color pages in a book and the walls in a
building.
When
the missionaries returned and gave a report they talked more about the
following: Great seafood that was really
cheap, great massages that were really cheap, the tour of an orchard that grew
exotic (to Americans) fruit that was really cheap, and the amazing animals they
saw at the zoo (by the way admission was really cheap). The leader concluded that not everyone thought
this trip was a good idea-here he glanced over to me-but, “When I saw the smile
on a little girl’s face I knew it was worth it.” Pardon me while I swallow back my vomit.
Okay,
I know that not every short-term mission trip is such a huge fiasco, but it is
time that we stop and look at the foundational premises behind our trips. If we do, we might find that a radical
rethinking of these mission trips is in order.
All I am asking is that we reconsider our perceptions and presumptions.
·
Short-term mission trips are a great way to recruit career
missionaries. While that was true at one
time, as we have dumbed down what happens on these trips we may not be
recruiting life-long missionaries as much as creating “Jesus tourism consumers”.
We need to look carefully at the numbers
and see if what was once true is still true.
·
The value of the mission trip cannot be measured in dollars. That is true.
However, as good stewards of God-given resources we need to have a sort
of spiritual “Return On Investment” evaluation.
To say, “If it helps one person the cost doesn’t matter,” is painfully
naive. What if those same resources used
in a different way could have helped 1,000 people? Stewardship is to some degree about the ROI,
the unrighteous servant returned the master’s money in full. It would have been better if he had a better
ROI.
·
By having short-term mission trips we can develop more long-term
support for the mission. This maybe the
only reason that missionaries in the field put up with the short-term mission
visits. But if the reason our people
support a mission is because they had an experience we have to ask hard
questions about motivations. We need to
look at our teaching about the universality of the church and our belonging to
each other as brothers and sisters in Christ.
To support the missions with which we have an experience is not too
unlike the motivation to be part of the Heritage USA scam of PTL fame.
·
Short-term mission trips change people. Ou, oux, oun! Greek for no, NO, NO. It is the Holy Spirit and the Word of God
that changes people. If the only way
people can change is to have them travel half way around the world so they can
imagine they are heroes to a group of lesser native people we have a profound
misunderstanding of, well, almost everything.
·
Short-term mission trips encourage believers. Sometimes this is very true. But, as we will see in a moment, there are
better ways to do this. But in some
cases the short-term mission trips are discouraging to the local
believers. Never forget that Americans
are high maintenance, expensive and quite frankly often not worth the
trouble. We need to stop thinking of
ourselves as the heroes whose presence is a dream come true for the native Christians. Those believers have a rescuer already, and
they may know Him better than we do.
So,
is there a positive solution? Yes, but it is not good for our ego. What if rather than spend tens of thousands
of dollars to send a group of people over there we brought one of their leaders
over here? If you look at the church in
Asia, Africa, the Middle East and South America you will find that in most ways
it is doing better than the church in America.
Maybe once you get beyond our wealth we really have very little to
offer. Once you get beyond the poverty
of third-world Christians they have much to offer to us. We might benefit from learning from our brothers
more than they benefit by our going and trying to solve their problems.
It
is likely that hosting a pastor for a month and having him teach us about
prayer, fasting and faithfulness under persecution would generate less
excitement than our plans to travel to an exotic location. We will likely have fewer car washes and bake
sales to bring him over and send him home with plenty of resources for ministry
than our “Jesus Tourism” trips would offer.
But the fact that we are so motivated by what we want and what appeals
to us is indicative of how dark our hearts really are.
To
return to the opening story the almost $20,000 spent for four American
Christians to color paper and walls, could have paid the full-time salary for a
minister for years. Instead, one
American has the subjective warm feeling of a little girl’s smile. If we think this is a good plan may God have
mercy on us.
Final
disclosure. I went on a well-planned,
short-term mission trip. I felt that at
best it was a dog and pony show. Even in
the midst I saw that we (the Americans) were not really accomplishing
much. And this was a well-planned
trip. However, my wife and I have for
many years supported a missionary who is a life-long native leader. He is reaching his people and doing it the
right way (See 2 Tim 2:2). We have
discussed the possibility of going over and seeing this long-time dear
friend. But we have come to the
conclusion that the many thousands of dollars to make such a trip would better
be used helping widows and orphans. Which by the way is something that his
ministry does. After all we will have
all of eternity to enjoy each other’s company as we worship God together.